nyccfb Follow us on Follow NYCCFB on Twitter
Searchable Database
 
Charter Revision ’99

OFFICIAL SUMMARY
Prepared by the City Clerk with the N.Y.C. Law Department.

These proposed amendments would revise the Charter of the City of New York as follows:


Gun-Free School Safety Zones and Gun Safety-Locking Devices

Currently, neither the Charter nor the Administrative Code prohibits gun possession near schools. This proposal would provide for the creation of “gun-free” school safety zones by making it illegal for individuals to possess or discharge any weapon (including handguns, pistols, rifles, shotguns, assault weapons and machine guns) within 1,000 feet of any school in the City. Violators would be subject to criminal and civil penalties. This proposal would provide for certain exceptions and affirmative defenses. It would not apply to police or federal law enforcement officers.

Currently, the Charter does not contain any gun safety lock requirements, but the Administrative Code provides that rifles and shotguns be sold with a safety-locking device that, if operative, would prevent individuals from pulling a weapon’s trigger. This proposal would require that all weapons, including handguns and pistols, have safety-locking devices when they are purchased or obtained and that safety-locking devices be used at all times in storing all firearms. Violators would face criminal and civil penalties.


Budget

Currently, neither the Charter nor the Administrative Code require that the City maintain a Budget Stabilization and Emergency Fund (although the Charter provides for a reserve which is maintained by state law at $100 million per year), but in its adopted budget for the last two years, the City has maintained a separate budget stabilization unit of appropriation. This proposal would require that at least fifty percent of any City surplus revenue be placed in a Budget Stabilization and Emergency Fund to be transferred by joint action of the Mayor and the City Council for a City need and, if not needed by the end of the fiscal year, to prepay future year’s debt service, which would include paying down long-term debt, or for financing capital projects (pay-as-you-go capital financing).

Under current Charter provisions, if the City Council seeks to increase City spending in the next fiscal year beyond the level of spending in the current year, it must establish higher real property tax rates than those for the current year, unless the Mayor’s estimate of the revenue that the City will receive from other sources in the next year permits the spending increase at current real property tax levels. This proposal would further limit year-to-year City spending increases generally to the rate of inflation as reflected in the regional Consumer Price Index. The Mayor and the City Council, upon their determination that it is in the best interest of the City, would jointly be authorized to exceed that limit for that fiscal year. This proposal would also require a written explanation for each instance where an increase in City-funded spending in an agency’s budget exceeds the rate of inflation. This proposal would also require that fiscal impact statements be issued by the City Council when it passes home rule requests seeking the enactment of legislation by the State of New York affecting the City.

Currently, the Charter requires that the City Council pass local laws and resolutions by a simple majority vote and if the Mayor vetoes a local law, the City Council may then override this veto by at least a two-thirds vote. This proposal would require at least a two-thirds vote of the City Council to pass any local law or resolution to impose a new tax or increase an existing non-real property tax and, if the Mayor vetoes such a local law or resolution, a four-fifths vote to override that veto.


The Commission on Human Rights

The Charter currently does not contain any provisions regarding the establishment of a City Commission on Human Rights to protect civil rights. The Administrative Code provides for such a commission to enforce the City’s Human Rights Law, which prohibits unlawful discrimination based on race, color, religion, creed, national origin, alienage, citizenship, gender, sexual orientation, disability, marital status, age and other protected classes. This proposal would establish the City’s Commission on Human Rights as a Charter agency empowered to enforce the provisions of the City’s Human Rights Law.


Immigrant Affairs

Currently, neither the Charter nor the Administrative Code requires the City to protect immigrants’ rights to access City services, to keep confidential the immigration status of individuals or to have an office or agency dedicated to immigrant affairs. The City has maintained such an office and such policies have been in place by executive order. This proposal would establish the Mayor’s Office of Immigrant Affairs and Language Services as a Charter agency to assist in the development and implementation of City policies and programs dedicated to immigrants. This proposal would incorporate into the Charter protection of immigrants’ rights to access City services and would authorize the Mayor to promulgate rules to require City agencies to maintain the confidentiality of immigration status and other private information.


Special Elections and Public Advocate

Currently, the Charter provides that, in the event of a mayoral vacancy, the Public Advocate succeeds to the Office of Mayor until a general election can be held to fill the vacancy. The Charter also provides for a nonpartisan special election within sixty days to fill vacancies in the Offices of Public Advocate, Comptroller, Borough President and City Council member, with nominations by independent nominating petitions, until a subsequent party primary and general election are later held to fill the vacancy. This proposal would provide that a special election be held within sixty days to fill a mayoral vacancy, similar in format to the procedure set forth in the Charter to fill vacancies in the Offices of Public Advocate, Comptroller, Borough President and City Council member, and that in special elections for the Offices of Mayor, Public Advocate and Comptroller, where no candidate receives forty percent or more of the vote, the two candidates receiving the most votes would advance to a run-off election to be held on the second Tuesday following the special election. This proposal would also eliminate the Public Advocate’s role to preside over City Council meetings or to vote in case of a tie and require that a voting member of the City Council, to be selected in accordance with rules to be promulgated by the City Council, would preside over City Council meetings. These proposals on special elections and the Public Advocate would not take effect until January 1, 2002.


Government Contracts

Currently, the Charter authorizes the City Council and Procurement Policy Board, by concurrent action, to establish dollar limits for “small purchases,” which, although subject to competition, are subject to less stringent procedures. The current small purchase limits are $25,000 for goods and services, $50,000 for construction and construction-related services, and $100,000 for information technology (although on January 1, 2001, the higher limit for information technology will expire and revert to the $25,000 level). This proposal would raise the small purchase limit to $100,000 for all procurements.

Currently, the Charter authorizes the City, under limited circumstances, to procure goods, services and construction without competition through any agency of the United States or the State of New York, but does not otherwise provide for the City to procure from, with or through another governmental entity without competition. This proposal would authorize such procurements.

Currently, the Charter contains provisions regarding bid deposit requirements, multi-step sealed proposals, and the debarment of contractors and requires agencies separately to maintain lists of prequalified vendors (under which vendors qualify in advance to participate in procurements). This proposal would eliminate these provisions and permit the Procurement Policy Board to use its rulemaking authority to address such matters. This proposal would explicitly authorize a centralized review of vendor integrity, performance and capability and centralized prequalification. It would eliminate the requirement that the Mayor approve procurements where prequalified lists are used.


Reorganizing City Government

Administration for Children’s Services. Currently, the Charter provides that the City Department of Social Services generally performs welfare functions, including those of child welfare. Pursuant to executive order, an Administration for Children’s Services (“ACS”) performs functions related to the care and protection of children. This proposal would establish ACS as a Charter agency to perform such functions, including the power to receive and investigate reports of child abuse and neglect, to assist families at risk by addressing the causes of abuse and neglect, to provide children and families with day care and preventative services to avert the impairment or dissolution of families, to place children in temporary foster care or permanent adoption when preventive services cannot redress causes of family neglect, to provide pre-school services, and to ensure that parents who are legally required to provide child support do so.

Organized Crime Control Commission. Currently, the Charter does not provide any agency with centralized jurisdiction over regulatory matters relating to the influence of organized crime in specific sectors of the economy. The Administrative Code provides several City agencies with regulatory, licensing and investigatory powers in connection with public wholesale food markets, the private carting industry and the shipboard gaming industry. This proposal would consolidate the jurisdiction of these several City agencies into a single Organized Crime Control Commission, which would be one Charter agency.

Department of Public Health and Mental Hygiene Services. Currently, the Charter provides for a Department of Health and a Department of Mental Health, Mental Retardation and Alcoholism Services. This proposal would consolidate the existing functions of these agencies into a Department of Public Health and Mental Hygiene Services. That department would have jurisdiction to regulate all matters and to perform all the functions that relate to public health in the City, including but not limited to the mental health, mental retardation, alcoholism and substance abuse services. This proposal would include provisions that address mental hygiene services in particular, including preparation of the budget for such services, creation of a division within the department to provide such services, and review of such services by the Mayor’s Office of Operations. The proposal would also require executive coordination of mental retardation and developmental disability services in the City through the Mayor’s Office of Operations.

Domestic Violence Services Coordination. Currently, the Charter does not contain any provisions regarding City services to prevent domestic violence, but such services are currently coordinated by a mayoral commission to combat family violence created by executive order. This proposal would require executive coordination (through the Mayor’s Office of Operations) of City services responding to domestic violence. That office would also be responsible for formulating policies and programs relating to all aspects of service delivery for victims of domestic violence.

Introduction
Official Text
Official Summary
History and Description
Highlights of the Major Arguments
Pro and Con Statements Received from the Public
New York State Ballot Proposal